Today's news -- November 29, 2017





Florida Constitution wrecking crew targets public schools *

The Florida Constitution Revision Commission is pursuing a radical agenda to undermine public schools and send public money to churches, mosques and synagogues. Today, a committee may well vote to repeal Florida’s historic ban on state aid to religious institutions, including religious schools. And it may vote to rip apart the constitutional requirement that there be a “uniform, efficient, safe, secure and high-quality system of free public schools.” This is wrong, all of it. And we doubt strongly that the people of Florida, who will have the last word on the commission’s recommendations, are as hostile to the public schools, or to the separation of church and state, as some politicians take them to be. Florida voters in 2012 emphatically defeated amendments to allow tax support of religious institutions and weaken maximum class-size requirements. And in 1998, they strongly supported an amendment to strengthen public schools by defining the education of children as a “paramount duty of the state.” The wrecking crew on today’s commission is ignoring a painful lesson voters taught the first commission in 1978: Don’t bite off more than Floridians care to chew. The 1978 panel overreached by proposing to abolish the elected Cabinet. Voters rejected that proposal 3-1, dragging down everything else the commissioners had proposed. That fight wasn’t personal for most voters. The fate of the schools will be. Nearly all Floridians owe their education to public schools or have children or grandchildren who do. The commissioners should focus on improving the schools, not on sabotage. Otherwise, they risk wasting their once-in-a-generation opportunity to send constitutional amendments directly to the ballot. As with any human institution, public schools can benefit from constructive criticism. There would be less cause for it, however, if Florida’s politicians and parents invested the attention and money the schools deserve. Society is far more complex than in the imperfectly remembered “good old days,” and public schools are tasked with problems such as poverty and racial bias that were once routinely ignored. It takes more than wishful thinking to get a child reading at grade level if no one ever read to her at home or her parents talk to the teacher only to complain. There is little a teacher can do to make up for what a parent won’t do. Plus, the Legislature has given private schools a competitive advantage over public schools. They don’t have to provide transportation, lunches or counseling. Their students aren’t rigorously tested and they can reject or expel pupils the public schools must take. A November 14 Education Week article describes Florida’s private school sector as “largely unregulated … with wide latitude over who it admits, who it kicks out, and few requirements for informing the public on how it serves students who are attending its schools with the help of taxpayer funds.” The article also told the story of a middle school student from Jupiter whose mother, upset with her public school, put her in a private school that soon closed. A second turned her down because she was lagging academically. A third kicked her out after the mother complained of bullying. Officials in Tallahassee did nothing. The child is now back in public school and doing well. The anti-public school proposals appear to have the backing of Gov. Rick Scott and House Speaker Richard Corcoran, whose appointees are sponsoring most of them. Marva Johnson, whose Proposal 59 would lift the ban on public funding of private schools, is a Scott appointee who also chairs the State Board of Education. Other harmful proposals include 45 and 71, which would enable the Legislature to spend money on private schools and authorize charter schools without local school board input. Both are by Commissioner Erika Donalds of Naples. To her credit, however, is proposal 33, calling for the appointment, rather than election, of all school superintendents. Another questionable proposal is number 93, by Commissioner Roberto Martinez, to let “high performing” school districts opt out of state regulation by becoming charter districts. His politically explosive Proposal 4, which would repeal the ban on sending taxpayer dollars to religious schools and organizations, is also on today’s agenda for the Declaration of Rights Committee, which seems predisposed to favor it. The only scheduled speaker on the subject is a Tallahassee lawyer who advocates for private schools. However, Lisa Carlton, the chair, says opponents will be heard. Martinez, a former U.S. Attorney for Florida’s Southern District, contends the ban is unconstitutional under a recent U.S. Supreme Court decision that allowed a church school in Missouri to receive playground equipment from the state on the same basis as nonreligious schools. There is sharp disagreement on his contention. David Barkey of Boca Raton, national religious freedom counsel for the Anti-Defamation League, argues that it was a narrow decision limited to playground resurfacing, not religious instruction. Florida’s separation of church and state was originally proclaimed in its 1885 constitution, and readopted by amendments in 1968 and 1998. Since the days of Thomas Jefferson and James Madison, it has been a fundamental tenet of American democracy that we don’t tax people to pay for other people’s religious practices. Our religious institutions are stronger, not weaker, for not being dependent on government handouts like the established church in colonial Virginia was. Jefferson’s 10-year struggle to end that was the origin of the First Amendment. The Constitution Revision Commission should not tamper with what has worked so well, for so long, for Florida and for the nation.


Elected vs. appointed? Florida’s superintendent selection process gets a closer look


Thousands enroll in Florida schools in wake of Hurricane Maria


New bullying bill has parents fuming


Teachers across Hillsborough head into day two of salary contract protest (Missy Keller quoted)


State education board OKs Duval school turnaround plans


Pinellas families rediscover their neighborhood school


Affordable housing? Broward school board looks to make it happen


Manatee school leader questions school tax


School doesn't show for appeal hearing over voucher ban


Nassau schools' bus driver shortage: One driver for every 84 students


States move toward requiring high schoolers to take civics to graduate


Mayfield, Altman push for mandatory CPR training in high schools


Video shows potentially dangerous conditions at Broward school


Health officials seeking Manatee students who developed cancer


Improving education requires much more than testing


Why it is unfair to compare charter schools to public schools


Do you want your child to be a guinea pig for the tech industry?


DeVos racks up more than a dozen visits to Florida schools


FAMU trustees could nominate Robinson for president this week (Elizabeth Davenport quoted)


Report: Adjunct faculty living in poverty


DeVos in Orlando: Student aid getting easier


GOP tax plan rattles higher education


Protect the G.I. Bill from the Republicans’ Tax Plan


Colleges puzzled by surge in FAFSA verification requests


Did the Legislature heed the warning in this 1997 sexual harassment case?


Voting groups oppose Scott’s push to disqualify justice


Voting restoration amendment has 900,000 signatures


Florida Chamber Foundation summit focuses on poverty, child care and education


State senator files bill to end daylight saving time observance


Florida company failed to supply Puerto Rico aid after it won FEMA contracts


E-verify requirement for businesses sought in Florida Constitution


Florida could be the GOP Waterloo in 2018 and 2020


CBO: Senate Republican tax bill takes billions from the poor


America is in crisis. The Republican tax plan will make that worse.


Senate GOP gets breathing room as tax plan advances


GOP’s new scheme to save Trump’s tax plan reveals the scam at its core


A deficit trigger can’t fix the GOP tax plan


10 Senate Republicans who could tank the tax bill


Republican victory may rest once again with McCain, this time on taxes


Pelosi, Schumer pull out of White House meeting after Trump attack


Inside the tweet that broke Trump's day, again


The rise and fall of the Trump-Schumer-Pelosi partnership


McConnell makes dubious claim that he never turned down Obama meeting


Senate’s tax plan would cut alcohol taxes. That would be a public health disaster.


A wild card expected today could put the Senate GOP tax bill in jeopardy


Senate considers making a terrible tax bill even worse


Republicans say the $1.5 trillion tax bill pays for itself, but experts disagree


What’s one more bad thing in the GOP tax bill? Ask the polar bears.


Nelson to Republicans on tax plan: Try again


Nelson could inadvertently help Republicans pass tax bill


Two Miami Republicans won’t vote for spending bill unless Dreamers are protected


DACA’s economic hit to Florida looms large, proponents say


Social platforms promised level playing field. Russian trolls proved that wrong.


A year ago, Trump promised Carrier workers help. We’re still waiting.


Trump ran for the “forgotten.” Then he forgot them.


Victorious Trump moves to reshape consumer bureau


This is a constitutional crisis


Note to Mulvaney: Donuts do not a CFPB director make


Net neutrality hits a nerve, eliciting intense reactions


From net neutrality to digital privacy, Congress does diddly


Supreme Court appears set to limit protections for company whistleblowers,amp.html


The Masterpiece Cakeshop case is not about religious freedom


EPA trots out coal baron to argue why Obama’s climate rule should be repealed


Trump should fire the EPA’s Scott Pruitt


Air Force failed to report dozens of violent service members to FBI gun databases


Sessions’ “failure to recall” gives defense lawyers new argument


The Trump administration’s incoherent stance on competition


North Korea’s latest missile launch appears to put U.S. capital in range


State Department suffers high profile exit as tensions with the White House grow


Pence says Trump “actively considering” moving U.S. embassy to Jerusalem


Is Trump going to lie our way into war with Iran?


Trump shares inflammatory anti-Muslim videos


Navajo Nation president calls Trump's “Pocahontas” quip an ethnic slur


Trump’s “Pocahontas” obsession reveals a central miscalculation of his presidency


Trump once said the “Access Hollywood” tape was real. Now he’s not sure.


“Access Hollywood” reminds Trump: “The tape is very real”


Will Trump have to answer to women who say he harassed and assaulted them?


Trump paid more than $1 million in labor settlement, documents reveal


The secret to a healthy relationship with the press


President’s tweets invite foreign crackdown on the press


Trump Foundation funding of O’Keefe was twice as much as previously reported


What O'Keefe doesn't get about the media


O’Keefe shows what real fake news is


Undercover activist rented apartment in home of top Democratic operative


NBC fires Lauer over sexual misconduct allegations



 0 user(s) rated this page
Login to leave a comment
No Comments yet