Delay teacher evaluation system until judge rules on union lawsuit

A Leon County Circuit Court judge has ruled that the teacher evaluations ordered up in 2011 by Gov. Rick Scott and the Legislature do not violate the Florida Constitution. So now they’re legal, but they’re still absurd. The Florida Education Association had asked the court to rule that the law requiring local school boards to tie pay to evaluation results violated teachers’ right to collective bargaining. The judge found, however, that meaningful negotiations can happen within the framework of evaluations. Too bad the evaluations themselves aren’t meaningful. Politicians and education bureaucrats continue to pretend that they can isolate the teacher’s role in a student’s success or failure from other variables that affect learning. That would be hard enough in a straightforward case, such as judging a student’s English teacher based on that student’s score on the reading FCAT. Evaluations get more complicated quickly if the district tries to account for variables such as days absent, disabilities and a native language other than English. The formulas don’t even try to account for socio-economic advantages and disadvantages -- a politically correct choice, though poverty and affluence can have profound effects. As teachers have emphasized, one aspect of Florida’s evaluation system is even more nonsensical. Because state-approved high-stakes tests are given in limited years in limited subjects, most teachers are evaluated at least in part based on scores of students they don’t even teach and/or in subjects they don’t teach. An 11th-grade calculus teacher’s evaluation, for example, can be based on 10th-graders’ reading FCAT scores. In theory, a time will come when every teacher can be evaluated based on end-of-course exams taken by his or her own students, though even then it will be hard to adjust for factors outside the teacher’s control. In a hopeful sign, Scott has expressed doubts about the evaluation system. The Legislature apparently doesn’t share those doubts. It overrode his wish to give teachers an across-the-board $2,500 raise, instead tying raises to evaluations. That snag mars the governor’s current “pep rally tour” of schools to celebrate the impending raises. But perhaps the judge’s ruling on collective bargaining will embolden school boards to be as flexible and generous as possible. We can see why the state judge did not throw out the evaluation system; some collective bargaining is possible. The teachers union can bring up a better issue, we think, in its recently filed federal lawsuit. The bogus evaluations are the central issue there. Since teachers can lose their jobs, promotions or raises based on scores of students they don’t teach, they have been denied due process guaranteed by the U.S. Constitution. Scott and Florida Education Secretary Tony Bennett should lead a push to delay implementation of the evaluation system until it can be shown to be valid. If they won’t protect Florida teachers, the federal courts should.


Teacher aides wonder if they'll get bonuses, too (Andy Ford quoted)


Baker teachers: health cost increases would shrink paychecks (Angela Callahan quoted)


Effort to fire Imagine Schools fails in Sarasota


School safety funding left largely unchanged


Scott touts rule repeal, end of teacher tenure, for economic rebound,0,


Support grows for moratorium on Common Core stakes

Growing numbers of teachers and parents across the country are very much in favor of the Common Core State Standards and want the implementation of these standards done right. As a result, they are calling on federal and state officials to put the brakes on the high stakes associated with Common Core assessments until the new standards are properly implemented and field-tested. "The momentum is building to step on the accelerator of quality implementation, and put the brakes on the stakes," AFT President Randi Weingarten said Thursday during a visit to the Oyler School in Cincinnati. "Teachers everywhere are speaking out. They know these standards can transform teaching and learning. But for that to happen, they need the necessary tools and resources to effectively teach the new standards." In the last 10 days, teachers and parents have sent more than 38,000 letters to U.S. Education Secretary Arne Duncan and state education commissioners across the nation asking them to stand with the AFT in its call for a moratorium on high-stakes consequences of Common Core tests. Meanwhile, teachers in nearly a dozen states staged actions in their schools Thursday that were designed to call attention to the need for a moratorium. The actions included mobilizing members by wearing blue shirts and buttons during the school day and other activities.


Federal court: Michigan schools can stop deducting union dues


Money cuts both ways in education


As Latinos make gains in education, gaps remain


Why Rhee’s test-driven incentives always fail


Does tracking of students bias value-added estimates for teachers?


How school privatizers buy state-level elections


University leaders expect Scott to veto tuition increase


Machen, UF trustees pleased with legislative support


After six months, state's FSCJ investigation still not complete (Karen Morian quoted)


Clock ticking for Scott to act on budget

It was only last Friday that lawmakers passed the $74.5 billion budget. Now, it's Gov. Rick Scott's turn. The 450-page document landed on Scott's desk Thursday. He has until May 24 to sign it -- and veto anything he doesn't deem appropriate. In his first year in office in 2011, Scott vetoed $615 million in member projects. Last year, Scott vetoed $143 million in various projects. He's been coy so far about what he's going to reject this year, but he'll have a lot to choose from. It's stuffed with hometown spending on cultural centers, water projects and college and university funding. The biggest single veto drama is whether Scott will deep-six the proposed 3 percent tuition hike.  University leaders are expecting Scott to veto it. Former Gov. Charlie Crist did the same thing in 2007. Although some questioned the legality of Crist's actions, Scott's general counsel says it set a precedent that puts Scott on solid ground if he does the same this year.


Scott's underwhelming leadership during legislative session,0,1276271.story


Two contrasting views of Florida's election law changes


Groups tell Florida high court that GOP skewed district lines for political edge,0,4326734.story


Citrus disease with no cure is ravaging florida groves


Reckless measure


Our swiftly melting deficit


Republican debt limit hostage operation hits record level of absurdity


Fast food workers strike in St. Louis


Will the effort to block Perez’s nomination backfire on Republicans?


Labor wrestles with its future (Richard Trumka quoted)

 0 user(s) rated this page
Login to leave a comment
No Comments yet